|
|
![]() |
|
|||||||||||||||||||
|
A 15-year old California girl wants to start up a Caucasian Club at her high school, much in the same spirit as the Black Student Union. The local NAACP chapter is naturally screaming racism. Hispanic and Asian groups have also voiced opposition. The student, Lisa McClelland, says she and her friends feel slighted (or is that slanted) by other ethnic clubs, and says that because the Caucasian Club admits all races, it's not racist. In fact, the club's aim is to, in her words, "solve the issues of racial disparity". Well, for starters, if you want to solve one issue, change the name of your little club. Seeings how you do admit anyone regardless of race, it really isn't a "caucasian" club, is it? On the other hand, Lisa may be on to something here. Are white kids prepared to participate in a truly multi-ethnic society? Do they need to unify as a race and undergo self-orientation? Worked for some other students, young Lisa points out, and rightfully so. Why couldn't it work positively for white kids? That's fair reasoning, isn't it? In her 15 years, she has seen examples where race and culture and identity have been made to matter. She's not blessed with the perspective of history. She doesn't know where she fits. And the problem is not black and white, literally. We're talking about California, where the proposed recall election ballot will be printed in seven different languages. Last I checked, white people were on the verge of becoming a minority in California. If trends continue, two-thirds of Californians will be non-white by 2040. A similar albeit slower trend is expected in the rest of the country. Previous generations haven't exactly "dealt", and they were still in charge. What is there to suggest that Lisa McClelland and her dwindling band of white well-intentioned friends can? And it's not limited to the halls of Anytown High: Rush Limbaugh can't seem to understand, as he characterizes it, the "social concern" for the NFL or the media to want to champion black quarterbacks like Donovan McNabb. Whether the League or the media actually does this is up to debate. But if paranoid white people actually believe this, do we as a society have an obligation to bring them up to speed? Or do we let them melt in their own ignorance and intolerance in the name of "payback"? (Or in Rush's case, allow him to get addicted to oxycontin and laugh it off because he's an ignorant cracker?). Most people know racism when they see it and hear it, just like most people know when their car needs service. But not of all us are mechanics. Pat yourself on the back all you want if it makes you feel better. But how do you fix it? It's very easy to sit here and criticize Rush and Lisa McClelland and others for not being as enlightened as the rest of us. The truth is, I'm probably not as enlightened as I think I am or as I should be. The world I've seen is limited to the socioeconomic hotbeds of Iowa and southern Illinois. I'm foolish to think that I've seen and experienced enough of the world to truly feel comfortable about it, and for the rest of the world to be comfortable about me. And argue with me all you want on this point, but the internet doesn't count. Until a firewall or a filter can protect people from suicide bombers, I have no idea what it's like to live in Jerusalem. Never confuse being well-read with being well-traveled. But that's another column. The best I can do is be a product of my own environment, which, while it does provide a fair amount of diversity, it's not California, and it's not the world. Funny that a few weeks ago, that world was obsessed, on every cable channel, on the front of every tabloid, all over the radio and all across the net, over the mysterious relationship status of a white Irish kid from Boston and a Puerto Rican girl from the Bronx. Mind you, hundreds of millions of dollars richer than most people fitting those respective racial profiles, but still. The "Bennifer" phenomenon is a passive example of racial and cultural harmony, and bank accounts aside, probably more representative of what most real relationships will look like in 20 years. Unless I'm not up on my far-right wing entertainment media (if there's such a thing), how did that slip under the radar? Truth is, it didn't. Most people don't view Jen and Ben as a ethnically mixed relationship as much as they see two rich hacks in love (Though I've yet to talk to my father about "that guy from that movie and the Mexican with the big ass"). The reason we hate on them has nothing to do with race. And the reason most Eagle fans boo Donovan McNabb (or better yet, Kordell Stewart) is because he's the QB of a lousy football team, and that gig carries with it a heavy dose of accountability. But how much longer should we mock a Lisa McClelland or a Rush Limbaugh for simply not getting it? Our conscience will allow most of us to let Rush take his racism, perceived or otherwise, to his grave. But in the case of Lisa McClelland, who shouldn't be expected to know better, that's a copout.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||